What is it? Why is it important?

The informed consent process describes how consent is obtained including procedures in the event participants withdraw, have to re-consent or are lost to follow-up.

Processes differ based on the following main aspects:

  • What is the target population of the study? Healthy volunteers, pregnant women, children, adolescents, persons unable to give consent, etc.
  • How complex is the study design? Placebo controlled studies, emergency situations, inclusion of legal representative, etc.
  • What are the expected study risks? First in man, intervention with novel drugs lacking extensive safety profiles, vulnerable target population
  • Is the aim to further use collected study data for research? Biological material and health related data

What do I need to do?

Based on the Swiss law, describe the consent process applicable to your study, such as:

  • Staff involved in consent acquisition
  • Means of informing and obtaining consent (e.g. in writing and/or orally, inclusion of witness or qualified translator)
  • Timing (e.g. post-hoc consent, incomplete information or step-wise consent)
  • Inclusion of participants by means of advertisement
  • Participant remuneration procedures
  • Further use of data and material from participants that withdrew or were lost to follow up

More

In order to ensure that the consent process is correctly implemented, during study conduct, ongoing surveillance is important.

Aspects to include:

  • The consent process of the study must be clearly described in the study protocol, including in a relevant SOP or WI
  • Staff is trained on the consent process and informed about any relevant changes to this process
  • During study conduct, only current and EC approved version of the ICF can be used for participant recruitment and consent
  • The ICF must be correctly dated and signed by both staff and study participant:
    • Only staff listed on the delegation log, and having been delegated the task of consent can sign and date the document
  • On the ICF:
    • All information except signatures are legible
    • For identification purposes, name of staff signing the ICF is entered
    • Participant name, date of birth is entered
    • Participants have personally dated and signed the document
    • If applicable, the time when the document was signed is entered
    • Participant and staff sign the ICF together at the same time
    • Study staff should never sign before the participant has entered his/her signature
  • The original signed and dated ICF:
    • Is filed in the ISF of the study site
    • A signed copy is handed out to participants

In the event of a substantial amendment that results in an adaptation of the PIS requires that participants:

  • Are informed about changes including potential consequences of the amendment (e.g. additional safety concerns, sampling of biological material, visits, data collection, and time investments).
  • Re-consent and sign the updated ICF (with date and signature)

All signed versions of the ICF are kept in the ISF of the study site.

Where can I get help?

Your local CTU↧ can support you with experienced staff regarding this topic

External Links

Swissethics – see in particular:

  • Checklist for the recruitment of study participants by means of advertising
  • Specimen text for advertisement
  • Guidelines on the retention period of biological material and personal data of further use projects without consent
  • Conception and application of an electronic informed consent
  • Time for consideration
  • Monetary contributions to patients participating in research projects

References

ICH GCP E6(R2) – see in particular guideline

  • 4.8. Informed consent of trial subjects

 

Declaration of Helsinki – see in particular principles

  • 25 – 32 Informed Consent

 

ISO 14155:2020 Medical devices (access liable to costs) - see in particular sections

  • 5.8 Informed consent

Swiss Law

HRA – see in particular articles and chapters

  • Art. 16 Informed consent
  • Art. 17 Consent to further use for research
  • Art. 18 Incomplete consent
  • Chapter 3, section 1. Research involving children, adolescents, adults lacking capacity.
  • Chapter 3, section 2. Research involving pregnant women, IFV embryos, foetuses
  • Chapter 3, section 3. Research involving prisoners
  • Chapter 3, section 4. Research in emergency situation

ClinO – see in particular articles

  • Art. 7 Informed Consent
  • Art. 8 Exception to the written form
  • Art. 9 Consequences of revocation of consent
  • Art. 15 Post hoc consent in emergency situations

HRO – see in particular articles and chapter

  • Art. 8 Informed Consent
  • Art. 9 Exception to the written form
  • Art. 10 Consequences of revocation of consent
  • Art.11 Research projects in emergency situations
  • Art. 41 Research involving deceased persons
  • Art. 44 Informed consent involving embryos and foetuses
  • Chapter 3, section 2. Informed consent and information in further use of biological material and health-related data
Abbreviations
  • ClinO – Clinical Trials Ordinance
  • CTU – Clinical Trials Unit EC – Ethics Committee
  • HRA – Human Research Act
  • HRO – Human Research Ordinance
  • ICF – Informed Consent Form
  • ICH GCP – International Council for Harmonisation Good Clinical Practice
  • ISF – Investigator Site File
  • ISO – International Organization for Standardization
  • PIS – Participant Information Sheet
  • SOP – Standard Operating Procedures
  • WI – Working Instructions
Development ↦ Management ↦ Study Documents ↦ Informed Consent Process
Study
Basic

Provides some background knowledge and basic definitions

Basic Protocol
Basic Management
  1. Study Management
    1. Definition
Basic Ethics and Laws
  1. Principles of Ethics Research
    1. Declaration of Helsinki
    2. Declaration of Taipei
  2. Authorities
    1. Ethics Committee
    2. Swissmedic
    3. Federal Office of Public Health
    4. International
  3. Swiss Law
    1. Human Research Act
    2. Transplantation Act
    3. Stem Cell Research Act
    4. Data Protection Act
  4. Clinical Trials Ordinance
    1. Aim
    2. Medicinal Products
    3. In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Device
    4. Standardized Transplant Products
    5. Gene Therapy, GMO, Pathogenic
    6. Transplantation
    7. Other Clinical Studies
    8. Ionising Radiation
  5. Human Research Ordinance
    1. Aim
    2. Projects with Data and Biological Material
    3. Further use of Data and Biological Material
    4. Further use and Informed Consent
    5. Deceased Persons Embryos and Foetuses
  6. Medical Device Ordinance
    1. Aim
    2. In Clinical Studies
    3. Notified Bodies
  7. Organisation Ordinance
    1. Aim
  8. Portals
    1. Human Research Portal
    2. Ethics Portal BASEC
    3. Swissmedic Portal
  9. Guidelines
    1. Good Clinical Practice
    2. ISO 14155
    3. ISO 20916
Basic Documents
  1. Document Management
    1. Purpose
    2. In Studies
    3. Document Identification
    4. Document Filing
  2. Standard Operating Procedures
    1. Purpose
  3. Working Instructions
    1. Purpose
  4. Logs
    1. Purpose
  5. Essential Documents
    1. Requirement
  6. Certified Copies
    1. Procedures
  7. Staff Documents
    1. Qualifications
    2. Training
Basic Safety
  1. Safety Laws
    1. Aim
  2. Safety Terminology
    1. Overview
  3. Safety Data
    1. Product Development
    2. Pre-Clinial Studies
    3. In Clinical Studies
  4. Safety Information
    1. Investigator Brochure
  5. Safety Vigilance
    1. Pharmacovigilance
    2. Materiovigilance
Basic Data Handling
  1. Data Management in Studies
    1. Aim
  2. Study Database
    1. Clinical Data Management System
    2. Study Data
    3. Raw Data
    4. Metadata
  3. Regulatory Requirements
    1. Swiss Law
    2. General Data Protection Regulation
Basic Statistics
Basic Quality and Risk
  1. Risk Management Definitions
    1. Risk-Based Approach
    2. Risk Identification
    3. Risk Evaluation and Prioritisation
    4. Risk Evaluation Matrix
    5. Risk Control Measures
  2. Quality Management System (QMS)
    1. Risk Based
  3. Risk-Based QMS Responsibilities
    1. Sponsor-Investigator
    2. Site-Investigator
    3. Study Staff
Basic Monitoring
Basic Drug or Device
Basic Biobanking
Concept

Starts with a study idea

Ends after having assessed and evaluated study feasibility

Concept Protocol
Concept Management
  1. Study Idea
    1. Implementation
    2. Design
  2. Resources
    1. Study Staff
    2. Infrastructure
    3. Storage
    4. Partners
    5. Budget
Concept Ethics and Laws
  1. Study Categorisation
    1. Procedures
    2. Risk Categories
  2. Regulatory Advice
    1. Scientific Advice
    2. Pre-Submission
  3. Regulatory Advice Meeting
    1. Ethics Clarification
  4. Research Aim
    1. Advancing Science
    2. Marketing Products
  5. Research Integrity
    1. Principles
    2. Conflict of Interest
    3. Participant Protection
  6. Study Planning
    1. Ethics Requirements
    2. Laws and Guidelines
    3. Institution Requirements
  7. Study Feasibility
    1. Ethics and Laws
Concept Documents
  1. Required Documents
    1. Protocol and Synopsis
    2. Feasibility
    3. Investigator's Brochure
Concept Safety
  1. Safety in Studies
    1. Risk-Benefit Ratio
    2. Participant Risk-Benefit
Concept Data Handling
  1. Stakeholders
    1. Sponsor-Investigator
    2. Data Manager
    3. Statistician
    4. Site-Investigator
    5. Monitor
  2. Clinical Data Mgmt. System
    1. Selection
  3. Server
    1. Data Storage
    2. Back-Up and Recovery
Concept Statistics
Concept Quality and Risk
  1. Study Feasibility
    1. Aim
    2. Feasibility Questionnaire
    3. Risk Assessment Form
    4. Study Team
Concept Monitoring
  1. Monitoring
    1. Aim
    2. Study Requirement
    3. Site Feasibility
Concept Drug or Device
Concept Biobanking
Development

Starts with confidence that the study is feasible

Ends after having received ethics and regulatory approval

Development Protocol
Development Management
  1. Responsibilities
    1. Sponsor-Investigator
    2. Site-Investigator
    3. Staff Qualification and Training
    4. Good Clinical Practice Training
  2. Quality Mgmt. System
    1. Implementation
    2. Interim Analysis
  3. Study Management
    1. Oversight
    2. Tracking
    3. Infratructure and Maintenance
    4. Multi-centre Studies
    5. Insurance
    6. Outsourced Services
    7. Contract
    8. Budget
  4. Study Documents
    1. Protocol
    2. Participant Information Sheet
    3. Informed Consent Form
    4. Exemption from written Consent
    5. Informed Consent Process
    6. General Consent
    7. Essential Documents
    8. Source Data
  5. Study Approval
    1. Ethics Committee
    2. Swissmedic
    3. Fed. Off. Public Health
  6. Biobanking
    1. Management
    2. Emergency Plan
Development Ethics and Laws
  1. Ethics Application
    1. Submission
    2. Application Dossier
    3. Approva
  2. Swissmedic Application
    1. Application Dossier
    2. Early Clarification Meeting
    3. Late Clarification Meeting
    4. Approval Medicinal Products
    5. Approval Medical Device
  3. Federal Office of Public Health
    1. Submission
    2. Approval
  4. Liability
    1. Insurance
    2. Good Clinical Practice
Development Documents
  1. Required Documents
    1. Study Protocol
    2. Participant Information
    3. Insurance and Contract
    4. Study Documents
    5. Document Submission
Development Safety
  1. Safety Documentation
    1. The Protocol
    2. Study Documents
    3. Data Protection
Development Data Handling
  1. Study Database Set-Up
    1. Variables
    2. Variable Specification
    3. Case Report Form
    4. Automated Data Processing
    5. Data Confidentiality
    6. Data Coding and Anonymisation
  2. Data Quality
    1. Requirement
    2. Quality Management
    3. Data Mgmt. Plan
  3. Database Lock
    1. Procedures
Development Statistics
Development Quality and Risk
  1. Study Risk Management
    1. Risk Identification
    2. Risk Evaluation and Prioritisation
    3. Risk Control Measures
    4. Process Verification and Training
  2. Quality Assurance
    1. Aim
    2. Quality Documents
    3. Audit
  3. Quality Control
    1. Aim
    2. Monitoring
    3. Non-Compliance
  4. Risk Communication
    1. Strategy
Development Monitoring
  1. Montoring Strategy
    1. Aim
    2. Risk-Based Monitoring
    3. On-Site Monitoring
    4. Central Monitoring
    5. Monitoring Plan
Development Drug or Device
Development Biobanking
Set-Up

Starts with ethics and regulatory approval

Ends after successful study initiation

Set-Up Protocol
Set-Up Management
  1. Registration
    1. Research Transparency
  2. Study Training
    1. Staff
  3. Document Management
    1. Requirements
  4. Investigational Product
    1. In Studies
  5. Laboratory
    1. Aim
  6. Study Ready for Conduct
    1. Requirements
  7. Study Monitoring
    1. Site Initiation Visit
Set-Up Ethics and Laws
  1. Study Set-Up
    1. Requirements
Set-Up Documents
  1. Required Documents
    1. Study Initiation
    2. Master and Site File
Set-Up Safety
  1. Safety Management
    1. Safety Management Plan
    2. Emergency Unblinding
  2. Data Safety Monitoring Board
    1. Aim
Set-Up Data Handling
  1. Database
    1. Development
    2. Access Rights
    3. Training
Set-Up Statistics
Set-Up Quality and Risk
Set-Up Monitoring
  1. Site Initation Visit
    1. Aim
    2. Prerequisite
    3. Preparation
    4. Conduct
    5. Report
Set-Up Drug or Device
Set-Up Biobanking
Conduct

Starts with participant recruitment

Ends after the last participant has completed the last study visit

Conduct Protocol
Conduct Management
  1. Participant Recruitment
    1. Pre-Screening
    2. Screening and Consent
    3. Documentation of Recruitment
  2. Amendment
    1. Protocol
    2. Patient Information Sheet
  3. Safety
    1. Reporting
    2. Annual Safety Reporting
    3. Interim Analysis
  4. Responsibility and Oversight
    1. Site-Investigator
    2. Routine Monitoring
    3. Risk Review
    4. Drug Accountability
    5. Compliance
    6. Newsletter
    7. Essential Documents
    8. Budget
Conduct Ethics and Laws
  1. Study Conduct
    1. Ongoing Tasks
    2. Data Protection
  2. Participant Protection
    1. Requirements
    2. Consent of Vulnerable Participants
  3. Amendment
    1. Type
    2. Submission
    3. Approval
  4. Safety
    1. Requirements
  5. Inspections and Audits
    1. Inspection Conduct
    2. Audit Conduct
    3. Audit Certificate
  6. Premature Study Termination
    1. Rationale
    2. ReportingTimelines
Conduct Documents
  1. Required Documents
    1. Study Documentation
    2. Patient File
    3. Source Data
    4. Amendment
Conduct Safety
  1. Safety Risk Review
    1. Aim
  2. Safety Assessment
    1. Medicinal Product
    2. Medical Device
    3. Other Clinical Trials
    4. Research Projects
  3. Safety Reporting
    1. Procedures
    2. Responsibilities
  4. Medicinal Product Safety Reporting
    1. Adverse Event
    2. Serious Adverse Event
    3. (Serious) Adverse Drug Reaction
    4. Suspected Unexpected Serious Adverse Reaction
    5. Advanced Therapies
  5. Medical Device Safety Reporting
    1. Adverse Event / Adverse Device Effect
    2. Serious Adverse Event and Device Effect
    3. Device Deficiency
  6. Research Project Safety Reporting
    1. Serious Events
  7. Safety and Protective Measures
    1. Procedures
  8. Annual Safety Report
    1. Procedures
Conduct Data Handling
  1. Data Entry
    1. Requirement
    2. Collection
  2. Data Quality
    1. Responsibility
    2. Training
  3. Data Handling
    1. Data Import
    2. Interim Lock
    3. Intermediate Data Eport
    4. Amendment
Conduct Statistics
Conduct Quality and Risk
  1. Risk Review
    1. Re-Evaluation
    2. Risk Documentation
  2. Deviation Documentation
    1. Note to File
  3. Regulatory Inspections
    1. Conduct
    2. Findings
    3. Corrective and Preventive Actions
Conduct Monitoring
  1. Routine Monitoring Visit
    1. Preparation
    2. Conduct
    3. Findings
    4. Report
    5. Follow-Up Letter
Conduct Drug or Device
Conduct Biobanking
Completion

Starts with last study visit completed

Ends after study publication and archiving

Completion Protocol
Completion Management
  1. Study Closure
    1. Close-Out Visit
    2. Database Lock
    3. Notification of Closure
    4. Lessons Learned
  2. Clinical Study Report
    1. Regulatory Requirements
  3. Publishing
    1. Study Registries
    2. Scientific Publications
  4. Archiving
    1. Storage
Completion Ethics and Laws
  1. End of Study Notification
    1. ReportingTimelines
    2. Liability Coverage
    3. Registry Update
  2. Clinical Study Report
    1. Procedures
  3. Publications
    1. Responsibilities
  4. Inspections and Audits
    1. Procedures
  5. Archiving
    1. Requirements
    2. Duration
Completion Documents
  1. Required Documents
    1. Study Closure
    2. Doument Archiving
    3. Document Destruction
Completion Safety
  1. Clinical Study Report
    1. Procedures
Completion Data Handling
  1. Final Database Lock
    1. Procedures
  2. Data Export
    1. Data Formatting and Tranfer
    2. Data Transfer Agreement
  3. Clinical Study Report
    1. Requirement
  4. Archiving
    1. Requirement
Completion Statistics
Completion Quality and Risk
  1. Clinical Study Report
    1. Risk Reporting
    2. Lessons Learned
  2. Archiving
    1. Study Records
Completion Monitoring
  1. Close-Out Visit
    1. Preparation
    2. Conduct
    3. Report
    4. Follow-Up Letter
    5. Archiving
Completion Drug or Device
Completion Biobanking
Current Path (click to copy): Development ↦ Management ↦ Study Documents ↦ Informed Consent Process

Please note: the Easy-GCS tool is currently under construction.